2D Platformer - Action When Key Is Pressed During Collision C#

Hello, I would appreciate any help provided by anyone. My issue is that I have a Player script which is attached to the Player, and I have a separate GameObject which is an Apple. The Apple has a Box Collider 2D on it, but what i'm wondering is how can I make a Debug.Log statement when the player is during the Collision and when the Player Presses 'E', the Debug.Log Statement works, because at the moment, it is not working. Here is the Void which is attached to the Player. (Hopefully this will give you a better Idea of what I need help with).

 void OnCollisionStay2D(Collision2D coll) {
         if (Input.GetKeyDown (KeyCode.E)) {
             if (coll.collider.tag == "Item") {
                 Debug.LogError ("Player Picked Up: " + "Apple" + "!");
             }
         }
     }

So this statement does not work for some reason. I've gone through and I thought it was correct. I've made sure of things such as the Apple having the tag 'Item', but for some reason it only prints the Debug.Log statement when the 2D Player is moving and then when you rapidly press 'E', then it sometimes prints the LogError. (By the way the LogError isn't actually an error, it just helps seeing the contrast between Debug.Log statements).

All help is very much appreciated. Thank You, Kind Regards, Trent!