Colors distorting when importing .psd or .png

Hi there! I've run into a strange problem best seen instead of described:

Things I've tried:

1. Deleting the background layer and adding an alpha channel

2. Disabling color management in Photoshop

3. Changing proof setup to sRGB in Photoshop

4. Converting to several different color profiles in Photoshop

5. Adjusting import setting in Unity, including format and filter mode

Any insight would be greatly appreciated! Have a great day! <3

-Brandon